Leverage and rising multiples did most of the work in buyout returns for more than a decade. McKinsey puts their share at 59% between 2010 and 2022. Capital has concentrated at the larger end of the market, and PitchBook says the upper middle market now looks like megadeal territory: richer multiples, more leverage, and less upside.
That leaves the lower middle market with less competition and cheaper entry. PitchBook finds that companies of $25 million to $100 million have returned a pooled 39% gross IRR since 2009, the highest of any size band.
Operator-led acquisitions have a long record of their own. Stanford’s 2026 Search Fund Study puts the aggregate public market equivalent for search funds at 2.88, with a median purchase price of $16 million in 2024 and 2025.
Background
Where Buyout Returns Came From
Share of buyout returns, 2010 to 2022
Multiple expansion and cheap leverage
McKinsey’s estimate of their share
59%All other sources
Everything else that drove returns
41%
McKinsey & Company, Private equity: Clearer view, tougher terrain (February 2026). McKinsey says multiple expansion and cheap leverage accounted for 59% of buyout returns between 2010 and 2022. The remaining 41% is all other sources.
Market Perspectives
What the Latest Data Shows
Less competition and cheaper entry at the smaller end.
Market Perspective
Q1 2026 US PE Middle Market Report
Q1 middle-market deal value reached $103.8 billion, up 10.7% from a year earlier, as capital concentrated in larger deals. Using SPI by StepStone data, PitchBook finds that smaller companies ($25 million to $100 million) have returned a pooled 39% gross IRR on realized or partially realized deals since 2009, the highest of any band. It calls the lower middle market the segment to watch in 2026.
PitchBook · Jun 2026
Industry Report
Search Funds Keep Offering a Proven Path to Ownership
Stanford’s 2026 Search Fund Study finds that search funds have consistently outperformed the S&P 500, with an aggregate public market equivalent of 2.88 across all search funds. Since 1996, about 58% have acquired a company, typically within about 20 months, and the median purchase price in 2024 and 2025 was $16 million.
Stanford GSB · Jul 2026
Market Perspective
Private Equity: Clearer View, Tougher Terrain
McKinsey says multiple expansion and cheap leverage accounted for 59% of buyout returns between 2010 and 2022. It expects operational value creation to be the primary source of returns for GPs and LPs.
McKinsey & Company · Feb 2026
Industry Report
GF Data Reports Show Steady Middle-Market Deal Flow Amid More Selective Financing Conditions in Q2
GF Data’s contributing private equity firms reported 85 completed transactions in the second quarter. Across the deals it tracks, the average purchase price was 7.0x trailing 12-month adjusted EBITDA, and average total debt on new platform buyouts was 2.9x.
GF Data · Aug 2026
From HalBar
Ownership Transition Is One of the Biggest Shifts in the Lower Middle Market.
“Profitable, stable businesses eventually reach a point where the owner is ready to step back. At the same time, experienced leaders are ready to acquire and operate a business, and long-term capital can support that transition. Those pieces only create an investment opportunity when they fit.”
HalBar Partners · LinkedIn · Nov 2026
Read on LinkedIn →One Question
Your Comfort With Leverage
In a lower middle market buyout, how much total debt relative to EBITDA are you comfortable with?
Responses are anonymous and will be compiled in HalBar’s year-end survey of the industry.
